Hard Drive comparison – Seagate or Toshiba, which is better?


Get hard drive comparison – what is the best hard drive? The best hard drives meet your storage demands without costing you a fortune. Hard drives are still the king of storage solutions if you want to get the most storage space for your money, and they’re the way to go if your budget isn’t flexible.  You have some choices to pick from to cater to your needs as well – whether you need one for the best gaming PC you just invested in or you’re looking for a secure external hard drive that can go wherever you go. Find more in Hard Drive comparison.

Consumer Reviews is supported by its audience. This website contains Paid Links. As an affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchase. Find more

What is an HDD?

An HDD is a data storage device that lives inside the computer. It has spinning disks inside where data is stored magnetically. The HDD has an arm with several “heads” (transducers) that read and write data on the disk. It is similar to how a turntable record player works, with an LP record (hard disk) and a needle on an arm (transducers). The arm moves the heads across the surface of the disk to access different data.

Who is this for – Hard Drive comparison?

  • Enthusiast multimedia users and heavy downloaders: Video collectors need space, and you can easily get to 8TB or much more space cheaply with a hard drive.
  • Budget buyers: Ditto. Plenty of cheap space. SSDs are too expensive for buyers of $300 PCs.
  • Graphic arts and engineering professionals: Video and photo editors fill up and wear out storage faster than most other folks. Replacing or adding a 2TB hard drive will be cheaper than replacing a 500GB SSD, though that gap is closing.
  • General users: These folks are a toss-up. Users who prefer to download or stash large amounts of their own media files locally will still need a hard drive with more capacity; SSDs get expensive quickly for big video and music collections. But if you mostly stream your music and videos online, buying a smaller SSD for the same money will give you a better experience.

Toshiba Hard Drive comparison

S300 Surveillance (3.5 inch)N300 NAS (3.5 inch)X300 Performance (3.5 inch)L200 Laptop PC (2.5 inch)
Application(2)Office Surveillance system, sDVR, sNVRSmall Office / Home Office Network systemGaming, Graphics, Photo/Video EditingMobile Computing, Console Gaming
Capacities(1)10TB, 8TB, 6TB, 4TB14TB, 12TB, 10TB, 8TB, 6TB, 4TB14TB, 12TB, 10TB, 8TB, 6TB, 4TB2TB, 1TB
InterfaceSATA 6 Gbit/sSATA 6 Gbit/sSATA 6 Gbit/sUp to SATA 6 Gbit/s
Recording TechnologyCMRCMRCMRDrive-Managed SMR
Rotational SpeedUp to 7200 RPM7200 RPM7200 RPM5400 RPM
Cache SizeUp to 256 MBUp to 256 MBUp to 256 MBUp to 128 MB
Drive Bays Supported(5)Up to 8Up to 8
Cameras SupportedUp to 64
24/7 Operation(9)
Workload Rate(6)Up to 180 TB/yrUp to 180 TB/yr

Toshiba vs Seagate hard drive comparison

Toshiba X300 12TB Performance & Gaming Internal Hard DriveSeagate BarraCuda 8TB Internal Hard Drive HDDSeagate Exos 7E8 8TB Internal Hard Drive HDD
Cache Memory Installed Size256.00256.00256.00
Digital Storage Capacity12 TB8 TB8 TB
Hard Disk Rotational Speed7200 rpm5400 rpm7200.0 rpm
Hard Disk Size12 TB8 TB
Hard Disk Form Factor3.50 inches3.50 inches3.50 inches
Hardware InterfaceSATA 6.0 Gb/sSATA 6.0 Gb/sSATA 6.0 Gb/s
Item Dimensions5.79 x 4.00 x 1.03 inches5.79 x 4.00 x 0.79 inches5.79 x 4.01 x 1.03 inches

Toshiba vs Western Digital hard drive comparison

Toshiba HDWR21CXZSTA X300 12TB Performance & Gaming Internal Hard Drive 7200 RPM SATA 6GB/s256 MB Cache 3.5 InchWestern Digital 6TB WD Black Performance Internal Hard Drive – 7200 RPM Class, SATA 6 Gb/s, 256 MB Cache, 3.5″ – WD6003FZBX
Cache Memory Installed Size256.00256.00
Digital Storage Capacity12 TB6 TB
Hard Disk Rotational Speed7200 rpm7200 rpm
Hard Disk Size12 TB6000
Hard Disk Form Factor3.50 inches3.50 inches
Hardware InterfaceSATA 6.0 Gb/sSATA 6.0 Gb/s
Item Dimensions5.79 x 4.00 x 1.03 inches5.79 x 4.00 x 1.03 inches

Detailed hard drive comparison – what is the best HDD?

Seagate FireCuda Mobile – Best laptop hard drive

Adds more pep to a laptop than an HDD


Interface: SATA 6GbpsCapacity: 500GB – 2TB + 8GBCache: 64 MBRPM: 5,400


+Multiple capacity options+Performance above a standard HDD


-Flash storage comes at a premium

Upgrading the storage in a laptop can be tough, since the hard drives are much smaller. There aren’t a lot of impressive 2.5-inch hard drives, as anything fast comes with a serious markup, but Seagate’s 2.5-inch FireCuda hybrid drive strikes a nice balance. It offers an easy way to add loads of storage to a laptop while also giving it a speed boost thanks to 8GB of flash storage. A five-year warranty on the drive will also help ensure it lasts a long time.

Toshiba X300 – Best for high capacity

Big drives at nimble speeds


Interface: SATA 6GbpsCapacity: 4 – 8TBCache: 128MBRPM: 7,200


+Massive storage+High speeds


-Short warranty

Even if its laptops aren’t as popular as they used to be, Toshiba is still a huge name in computing, and has a lot to offer. When it comes to the best hard drives, the Toshiba X300 is a high-capacity, high-performance champ worth taking a look at. The X300 drives boast great gigabyte-to-dollar value without sacrificing on performance. These drives all spin at 7,200 rpm and include 128MB of cache for higher speeds. The only downside is the warranty only lasts two years, which feels short for a drive meant to store so much important data.

Seagate BarraCuda – Best hard drive

High RPM and storage at a low price


Interface: SATA 6GbpsCapacity: 2 – 3TBCache: 64MBRPM: 7,200


+Low cost+Fast spinning disks


– Limited cache

It’s almost impossible to talk about hard drives without mentioning Seagate’s BarraCuda lineup – it’s a force to be reckoned with. And, it’s not hard to see why, Seagate BarraCuda drives offer a great gigabyte-per-dollar ratio and speed benefits to top it off. The 2TB model hits a sweet spot by balancing high performance and affordability. Since this drive combines 7,200rpm platters and high density data, computers outfitted with this drive will be able to read data extraordinarily fast.

WD Blue Desktop – Best budget hard drive

Heavy on storage, light on price


Interface: SATA 6GbpsCapacity: 500GB – 6TBCache: 64MBRPM: 5,400 – 7,200


+An option for every budget+Faster option available


-Less value from smaller drives

Western Digital offers a solid bargain with its line of WD Blue hard drives. With a wide variety of storage options from a small 500GB to a capacious 6TB, the WD Blue is a viable pick for almost any type of PC build that’s sticking to a budget. The best value comes from the larger drives – they’ll give you much more storage per dollar spent. And, if you’re looking for a bit more speed, there are also 7,200rpm models available that don’t come with too much of a price hike. 

WD VelociRaptor – Best gaming hard drive

Faster spinning, faster gaming


Interface: SATA 6GbpsCapacity: 250GB – 1TBCache: 64MBRPM: 10,000


+Insane HDD speed+Built-on cooler


-Priced like an SSD

When it comes to PC gaming, it’s better to be fast than capacious. So, if you’ve been resisting the allure of an SSD, and looking to kick it old school with one of the best hard drives, the WD VelociRaptor should be up your alley. Not only does this drive have a whopping 10,000 rpm spin speed, but you’re going to want to pay attention to it. With capacities up to 1TB, the VelociRaptor drives are ready to store large game libraries, and the super fast platters will help your games launch and load quickly.

Seagate Firecuda Desktop – Best hybrid hard drive

Faster than a HDD, cheaper than an SSD


Interface: SATA 6GbpsCapacity: 1TB – 2TB + 8GBCache: 64 MBRPM: 7,200


+NAND-boosted performance+An already fast platter


-No competition

SSDs are incredibly popular, and it’s not hard to see why. But, if you need a lot of fast storage, and you don’t have a vault of cash, hybrid hard drives are a great option. The SeaGate FireCuda is the best hybrid hard drive on the market. It can fit up to 2TB of data, and then its 8GB of solid state cache storage learns which data you use most, so that you can access it quickly. That speed boost is even sweeter when you consider that this drive spins at 7,200rpm. With a 5-year warranty and an approachable price tag, it’s easy to see why this is one of the best hard drives you can buy today.

G-Technology G-Drive : Best external hard drive

Life in spinning disks


Interface: USB 3.1 (Type-C)Capacity: 4 – 10TB


+ Fantastic performance + USB Type-C V2 


– Bigger than expected 

A lot of people seem to think that the best hard drives are ancient and dead technology in 2020. However, with devices like the G-Technology G-Drive, you can show the naysayers in your life that spinning disks have their own place in the future. Not only does this external hard drive offer huge amounts of storage – up to 10 TB – but thanks to Thunderbolt 3 compatibility, it can even charge your laptop while you work. If you have a MacBook Pro, it’s hard to think of a better work companion.

Seagate IronWolf NAS – Best NAS hard drive

Storage-galore for the network


Interface: SATA 6GbpsCapacity: 6 – 12TBCache: 256MBRPM: 7,200


+Ready for RAID+Faster than smaller options


-Pricier than non-NAS drives

It’s a little unfortunate that the Seagate IronWolf NAS drives come at a premium, but they aren’t priced much more expensively than a standard hard drive at their capacity. However, their native NAS optimization makes that premium totally worth it. These drives are capable of running at a fast 7,200rpm spin rate 24/7 without having to worry about drive failure. Really, if you have one of the best NAS devices for your business or home, the Seagate IronWolf NAS really is your best bet. 

WD My Book – Best game console hard drive

For when you need to fit all the games


Interface: USB 3.0Capacity: 3 – 20TB


+Massive storage options+Simpler upgrade solution


-Potentially slower

Game consoles hard drives fill up fast with massive libraries. And, like laptops, the upgrade path for 2.5-inch hard drives isn’t all that great, but that’s where an external drive comes in. The WD My Book strikes an amazing balance of storage and price, offering enough room for massive game libraries. Running on USB 3.0, it may not be quite as fast as an internal drive upgrade, but it will run games and offer more storage at a cheaper rate.

Editor’s recommendations

Lead Content Editor
Lead Content Editor

I enjoy creating stuff and giving back to my community. My days are spent producing content for brands who need an internet presence and for things that I adore. I bring with me six years of experience generating content and obtaining leads from untapped markets. I concentrate on the qualities and advantages of the goods that add value for my audience. After reading my reviews, anyone who want to purchase a product from me are given my honest and open recommendation. I integrate my reviews with those of actual people to make the content authentic and accurate. Please take a moment to contact me if you see any deviations; I always value and appreciate hearing from my readers.

Articles: 1373