TiVo Edge vs Xfinity X1 premium DVR plan cost comparison

TiVo Edge vs Xfinity X1 premium DVR plan cost comparison

Should you invest in Xfinity X1 DVR in 2022? Which has more features and less plan cost? Comcast is licensing TiVo’s software, Comcast TiVo’s won’t have the full functionality of a regular TiVo. For instance, Comcast doesn’t have access to TiVo’s partnerships with Hulu, Netflix and other third-party companies. Also, customers who have a Comcast TiVo do not own the DVR, whereas customers who purchase a TiVo from TiVo or an electronics retailer own the box. Explore benefits in TiVo Edge vs Xfinity X1 premium DVR plan cost comparison.

Consumer Reviews is supported by its audience. This website contains Paid Links. As an affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchase. Find more

Pros & Cons – TiVo Edge vs Xfinity X1

TiVo Edge

Pros:

  • OnDemand is back.
  • Free Netflix account.
  • Free Peacock account
  • Voice control works great
  • Tivo’s commercial skip is better

Cons:

  • Requires subscription

Xfinity X1

Pros

  • You’ll get to choose from three different DVR storage plans
  • The X1 provides smooth technology
  • It comes with an X1 voice remote control

Cons

  • The fees for the X1 can get pricey
  • Manual recording

What are the key differences – TiVo Edge vs Xfinity X1?

Design

TiVo Edge measures 1.8 by 11.4 by 7.3 inches (HWD) and weighs 1.9 pounds, making it shorter and sleeker than the boxy Fire TV Recast. The TiVo Edge looks like a stack of two flat, glossy black plastic boxes.

The Xfinity X1 is one of the best DVRs in the cable TV industry, primarily because of its features and technology. But the X1 might not be the best when it comes to pricing. It is box shaped and compact.

Connectors

TiVo Edge

The port arrangement around back has barely changed despite the new look, with a coaxial input, optical audio output, HDMI, a pair of USB ports, ethernet, and a remote finder button that plays a tone on the TiVo remote.

Xfinity X1

There are LED indicator to show the different status and power option. It comes with a HDMI option to connect your smart TV.

Storage

TiVo Edge

TiVos have recording capacities that range from 75 to 450 hours, depending on whether it is standard definition or high definition, and which device you are using. You can choose from three models of the Roamio. The base model costs $200 and has 75 hours of capacity. The menu and features are more limited on this one than on the others. 

Xfinity X1

The X1 Cloud DVR can store 20, 150, or 300 SD hours, and your recordings will save indefinitely.

Compared to other cable TV services, the X1’s storage space sits in the middle of the pack (scroll down a little for more comparisons).How much storage space does the Xfinity X1 have?

DVRStorage spaceStorage hoursSimultaneous recordingsDVR service fee
X1 DVR500 GB20, 150, or 300 SD hours6$10.00/mo.

To put 150 hours in perspective, you can record 30 episodes of The Office, 30 episodes of Family Feud, 20 episodes of The Murder Tapes, 10 soccer games, and 28 movies.

HDR image

High-definition TV broadcasts are largely limited to 720p and 1080i formats, both of which have less detail than the standard 1080p HD format used by most streaming media. Fortunately, the TiVo Edge also incorporates a handful of streaming services into its system, and can output video to your TV at up to 4K resolution at 60 frames per second.

I have noticed a peculiarity where I set the X1 to 2160p60 4K UHD and the next day it has changed to 1080p60 HD (for Sony Bravia is 4K UHD). I’d say, for me, that 1080p60 HD looks the same as my TiVo Roamio, while 2160p60 4K UHD looks a little better than the TiVo Roamio.

Channels jump

On the TiVo you enter the new channel number and it changes to that channel. On the X1 you enter the new channel number and get a search box where you select the channel (it’s always the top-most result) and press the center OK button. I need to use voice control more often to change channels, it works quite well and is faster than the search method.

Tuners use

I loved being able to switch tuners on the TiVo and having each tuner have a 30 minute buffer. There is no way on an X1 to switch tuners, but the left-arrow button on the remote lets you quickly and easily change channels (to the last nine channels you’ve used) but there is no buffer. I believe the X1 has a 60 minute buffer when you stay on one channel. I have not investigated X1’s “Favorites” feature yet.

What are the similarities – TiVo Edge vs Xfinity X1 premium DVR?

TiVo Edge

As for TiVo’s remote, it remains aggressively chunky with too many extraneous buttons (TiVo’s recommendations don’t even utilize the thumbs-up and -down buttons anymore), but the TiVo Edge for Antenna remote has one major improvement this time around: It’s backlit, so the keys light up when you press them. Strangely, TiVo is sticking cable customers with the non-backlit version for now.

Xfinity X1 Remote

The X1 remote is so impressive, it’s almost worth subscribing to the service just to gain access to it. (We did say almost.) The Xfinity voice remote allows you to perform a variety of functions simply by speaking, including:

  • Changing channels
  • Finding a specific show
  • Finding shows with a certain actor
  • Finding songs with a certain musician
  • Finding particular sports programming
  • Finding games of particular teams
  • Searching the on demand library
  • Controlling the DVR
  • Opening apps

TiVo Edge vs Xfinity X1 premium DVR plan cost comparison

TiVo Edge

TiVo continues to require a subscription, and for the TiVo Edge for Antenna that means $6.99 per month or $69.99 per year to use the DVR (you can also go all-in with a lifetime subscription for $249.99). The TiVo Edge for Cable subscription is considerably more expensive at $14.99 per month or $149.99 per year, or $549.99 to go all-in with a lifetime subscription.

Xfinity X1

Your first TV box is $5 per month, and the additional TV box’s for your living room downstairs and your kid’s bedroom will be $10 per month each. And depending on how much your household records TV shows and movies will determine if you spend $0 per month for your included 20-hour DVR service, $10 for 150 storage hours, or $20 for 300.

So your X1 experience could be $45 per month on top of the monthly TV package price. Yikes.

How much are the fees for Comcast Xfinity’s X1 DVR?

FeeMonthly price*
First TV box$5.00/mo.
Additional TV box$9.95/mo.
DVR fee$0.00–$20.00/mo.

TiVo Bolt vs Xfinity X1

Only TiVo offers:

  • SkipMode: Skip entire commercial breaks of recorded shows with a single button1.
  • QuickMode: Watch shows 30% faster, without the “chipmunk-effect.”
  • Built-in mobile streaming: Stream live and recorded shows to your mobile device at home or download them for the road2.
  • Tru Multi-Room: Pause, rewind and control live TV or schedule recordings in any room with TiVo Mini3.
  • Save money: Avoid additional pesky monthly service fees with a multi-room setup.

Is TiVo BOLT better than Comcast Xfinity X1? We think so. But compare for yourself and see why millions of households have chosen TiVo.

ServicesTiVo BOLTXFINITY X1
Commercial SkipYesNo
Watch FasterYesNo
Streaming ServicesYesNo
Whole HomeYesNo
PriceYesNo

Compare TiVo Edge vs Xfinity X1 premium DVR plan cost with others

We’ll give you a quick rundown:

  • Xfinity TV‘s first cable box is $5 per month, additional are $10, and the DVR service is $0–20.
  • Spectrum TV‘s monthly price for one receiver is $9. The DVR service for two receivers is the same price as the X1, but you’ll get only one-third of the storage space.
  • Verizon Fios TV includes the first set-top box with two of its plans. If you’d like 500 HD hours of storage space, your monthly price will be $20 (that’s the price of Xfinity’s DVR service for 150 HD/ 300 SD hours).
  • Optimum TV charges $11 per month for each cable TV box. To get the same storage space as the X1, the monthly fee will cost $22.
  • Cox TV includes the first set-top box in your plan. And Cox TV certainly has the most generous DVR storage space, but you’ll have to pay $30 each month for the 1,000-hour DVR service.
DVRDVR storage spaceSimultaneous recordings
Xfinity’s X120–300 SD hours6
Spectrum TV’s DVR35 HD/80 SD hours2
Verizon Fios TV’s DVR50-100 HD/100-500 SD hours2-6
Optimum TV’s DVR25-150 HD hours15
Cox TV’s DVR250-1,000 HD hours2-24

TiVo Edge vs Xfinity X1 alternative

Apple TV 4K (2021)

SPECIFICATIONS

Number of Apps: ThousandsSize: 3.9 x 3.9 x 1.4 inchesWeight: 15.0 oz

REASONS TO BUY

+New, improved remote+High frame rate HDR streaming+Multi-user support

REASONS TO AVOID

-Expensive-Not noticeably better than first-genAdvertisement

The new Apple TV 4K (2021) is great and performs like a dream — yet still may not be worth the upgrade if you already have the previous model. On the outside, the 2nd-gen Apple TV 4K looks identical to its predecessor. The upgrades are all on the inside, notably replacing the A10X chip with an A12 Bionic. Performance seems a few hairs better, plus the Apple TV 4K 2nd-gen supports 4K at 60fps with HDR versus 30fps. Not a ton of apps even offer that level of content right now, mostly sports and other fast-paced action, but it will become more prevalent. 

The best thing about the new Apple TV 4K is the redesigned Siri Remote. Many (myself included) hated the old remote and its frustrating touch interface. The new remote retains touch and gestures, but adds actual buttons as well as an intuitive jog wheel that recalls the old iPods of yore. Once again, though, the biggest drawback is the price. 

Editor’s recommendations